|
A cement can also be unsound due to presence of MgO,
which reacts with water in a manner similar to CaO. However, only
Periclase(crystalline MgO) is deleteriously reactive, while MgO present in glass
is harmless.
The effect of excess crystalline free MgO (periclase)
on cement soundness and concrete durability under actual service conditions is
often considered questionable as there is very little data correlating the percentage of MgO (or periclase), autoclave
expansion test results, and the actual field performance of concrete.
In a
study of sound and unsound cements, Narang et al. (1981) demonstrated the
effects of cement fineness on autoclave expansion. A high MgO-content cement
ground to a fineness of 225 m2/kg showed an autoclave expansion of
7.06%. When the cement was ground to a higher fineness of 350 m2/kg,
the autoclave expansion dropped to 1.39%, and finally when the fineness was
increased to a value of 400 m2/kg, the resulting autoclave expansion
was only 0.24%. It was also found that cement ground from a rapidly cooled
clinker gave a low autoclave expansion.
Thus, one of the factors that influence
the amount of expansion that will occur when a cement is autoclaved is the
fineness or specific surface area of the cement being tested. Coarser ground
cements have always exhibited a greater amount autoclave expansion, all other
things being equal.
It has been
suggested that the autoclave expansion test is highly conservative and will exclude cements that would otherwise
demonstrate acceptable field performance characteristics with no reduction in
long-term durability. In fact, there have been no reported cases of concrete
failure within the last 60 to 100 years in the U.S. that can be attributed to a free MgO-induced
unsoundness condition. However, this could well be the result of having such a rigorous autoclave
expansion test requirement in the ASTM C 150, Standard Specification for
Portland Cement.
|